Results indicated that there were few differences between the Direct File youths and Adult Offenders. In agreement with Stier, I consider that juveniles have greater possibility than adults to make a change in their lives with the right help, counseling and rehabilitation.
We have seen today in society how crime rates have been sky rocketing and how statistics prove that the majority of the crimes are being done by minors. Thesis Statement Many adults come up with many reasons why youth involve Should juveniles be tried as adults? It is a shame that many people at young ages decide to live a life of misdeeds and become what we call juvenile criminals, but, every action has a consequence and to deal with these unlawful adolescent we have the Juvenile Justice Department.
To test this hypothesis, we compared the competence-related abilities and developmental characteristics of a sample of direct-filed year-olds charged in criminal court in the state of Florida Direct File sample to a sample of year-old adults charged in criminal courts Adult Offender sample and to a separate sample of year-olds charged in juvenile court Juvenile Court sample.
Annotated Bibliography Fagan, Jeffrey.
He also discusses how many advocates and academics argue that juveniles are not being given enough of a chance to turn their lives around after committing minor offenses. Should Juvenile Criminals be tried as Adults?
Every day, judges and prosecutors make complex decisions about whether young offenders should be tried as juveniles or adults. However I am not stating that is an excuse to do the same wrong.
Most young criminals are also controlled by organizations run by unlawful adults who promise them a way out of poverty and misery when they truly are shortening their lives. Being tried as adults exposes these juveniles to state penitentiaries and sentences up to life in prison without parole and even execution.
The relative immaturity of adolescents suggests that transferred youths might have impaired competence-related abilities compared to adults. Poythress, Norman, et al. The differences that were observed suggested that the Direct Filed youths performed slightly better than the Adult Offender group and the Juvenile Court youths charged in juvenile court.
Do these juveniles have the capacity to truly understand the crimes they are committing? They also argue the fact that in most states they do not specifically analyze if a minor is competent to proceed in criminal court as a requirement for judicial waiver unless he or she presents a mental disorder.
If someone is raised in a violent environment where they physically or visually experience cruelty, they are more likely to do the same. These questions leave us wondering if this notion really is effective or is there a better way of handling young criminals.
I believe that when you look into the background of these young delinquents most of them come disproportionately from impoverished single parents homes located in disinvested neighborhoods and have high rates of learning disabilities, mental health, and substance abuse problems and with help of the juvenile justice system they can make a huge turn into a successful transition in to adulthood.
Adults are not the only ones that commit crimes. It is common sense that humans adapts to their surroundings and are influenced by their upbringing that can determine who he or she may be in the future. This entry was posted on December 1, by ruth In todays society, there are many crimes going on.
This being they are not fully mentally stable and developed in difference with adults who have full capacity and judgment to their actions this discarding criminal with mental incapacities. We have to realize that the people around us influence or actions and our change of character.
Is there something or someone behind the acts of these young offenders? These minors range from the ages of nine to twenty depending on the crime committed or on how many times they are prosecuted and believe to be unchangeable.
The different situations are endless but I believe they should not be implemented into adult penitentiaries, especially those younger than eighteen.
There comes a time in our lives when we have to decide who we ought to be. Is there an age limit for introducing these juveniles into the adult justice system? In some cases they are waivered into the adult system automatically such as in homicide cases.
It called for the youth and adult criminal justice systems to be merged into one, but with sentencing and provision based on maturity, not chronological age.
Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: They should be placed with those their age group even though their sentencing can be that of an adult. Some say stop trying them as adults and try them as juveniles, others say they must be tried as adults when they commit adult crimes.
Such approaches have been tried elsewhere in Europe, the inquiry said. They are exposed to the harsh cruelty of penitentiary life where most are raped, beaten, and subjected to any abuse seen and known in these prisons no matter their age, mental and emotional state.
It was filed under Uncategorized.Should juveniles be tried as adults pros and cons essay. Should Juvenile Offenders Be Tried As Adults Criminology Essay 23 Mar Should Juvenile Offenders Be Tried As Adults Criminology Essay.
Should Juveniles be tried as adults in the Justice System, or should they have to endure the same punishment.
Delinquency in the Juvenile Justice system was really low in the 90’s. Crimes committed now by young offenders are getting high since the 90’s. Moreover, often children that commit crimes come from broken homes.
Generally, juveniles should be punished for their wrong doings; however, as many people have pointed out, the goal of incarceration should be rehabilitation. Juveniles who commit serious crimes are being punished for their actions, but the possible solution to juvenile’s crime would be rehabilitation.
By them going to this institution it can help them become more of a positive person inside and out. Juvenile Punishment essaysA serious question has been posed as to whether or not children should be treated as adults when they commit serious crimes.
Unfortunately, no one knows the answer. Each case should be handled based on its own facts and circumstances surrounding the crime. Those who believe that juveniles should receive adult penalties for serious crimes often claim that the young children are not fully aware of the crime they commit and .Download